The Use of Personal Guarantees for Combatting Invoice Finance Fraud

Image: Francesco Ungaro/francesco_ungaro/Unsplash
Image: Francesco Ungaro/francesco_ungaro/Unsplash

Invoice finance is a valuable tool for businesses seeking to improve their cash flow by leveraging outstanding invoices. However, this financial service is susceptible to fraud, which can have severe implications for both finance providers and businesses. One method which finance providers use to mitigate the risk of fraud is requiring personal guarantees. This article explores the relationship between invoice finance fraud and personal guarantees, discussing how they work together to protect the finance provider and the best practices for managing these risks.

 

 

Understanding Invoice Finance Fraud

 

Invoice finance fraud involves deceptive practices where businesses or individuals manipulate or fabricate invoices to secure financing. Common types of invoice finance fraud include:

 

·         Fresh Air Invoices

 

Creating invoices for non-existent goods or services.

 

·         Overstated Invoices

 

Inflating the value of legitimate invoices.

 

·         Duplicate Invoices

 

Submitting the same invoice to multiple finance providers.

 

·         Pre-Invoicing

 

Issuing invoices before goods are shipped or services are rendered.

 

·         Fraudulent Companies

 

Establishing shell companies solely to commit fraud. These entities create a network of fraudulent transactions and invoices to deceive finance providers.

 

The Role of Personal Guarantees

 

A personal guarantee is a commitment by an individual, typically a company director, to repay a debt personally if the business fails to meet its obligations. In the context of invoice finance, personal guarantees serve as an additional layer of security for finance providers, ensuring that they have recourse in the event of fraud or default (and, indeed, for it to act as a deterrent).

 

In some cases, the personal guarantee may be limited to a specific figure, however, the terms of the personal guarantee may be such that the fraud invalidates the limited nature of the guarantee and widens the scope allowing all funding obtained by fraudulent means to be recoverable.

 

It is important to ensure that the terms of the invoice financing agreement and any personal guarantees are carefully drafted to cover all eventualities including fraud. 

 

Benefits of Personal Guarantees

 

·         Risk Mitigation

 

Personal guarantees reduce the financial risk for finance providers by providing an alternative source of repayment

 

·         Accountability

 

They hold business owners personally accountable, discouraging fraudulent behaviour.

 

·         Confidence

 

Personal guarantees give finance providers more confidence to extend credit, knowing they have additional protection.

 

How Personal Guarantees Help Combat Invoice Finance Fraud

 

·         Deterrence

 

The requirement of a personal guarantee acts as a deterrent against fraud. Business owners are less likely to engage in fraudulent activities if they know their personal assets are at stake.

 

·         Enhanced Due Diligence

 

When a personal guarantee is involved, finance providers typically conduct more thorough due diligence. This includes verifying the personal financial standing of the guarantor, which can help identify potential ‘red flags’ before extending credit.

 

·         Improved Recovery Options

 

In the event of fraud or default, finance providers can pursue the personal guarantor’s assets to recover the outstanding debt. This additional recourse can significantly reduce losses.

 

Best Practices for Finance Providers

 

·         Thorough Vetting of Guarantors

 

Conduct comprehensive background checks on personal guarantors. Verify their financial stability, credit history, and any past involvement in fraudulent activities. Implement ‘Know Your Customer’ (KYC) procedures to confirm the identities of directors, shareholders, and key personnel

 

·         Employee Training and Awareness

 

Fraud Detection Training: Train employees to recognise signs of potential fraud, such as inconsistencies in invoice details, sudden spikes in invoicing, or reluctance from clients to provide documentation.

 

Reporting Mechanisms: Establish clear procedures for employees to report suspicious activities or concerns related to invoice finance fraud.

 

·         Clear Contractual Terms

 

Clearly outline the terms of the personal guarantee in the financing agreement. Specify the conditions under which the guarantee will be enforced and the extent of the guarantor’s liability.

 

·         Regular Monitoring

 

Continuously monitor the business and its transactions. Implement systems to detect anomalies and potential signs of fraud in real-time.

 

·         Legal Advice

 

Seek legal advice when drafting personal guarantee agreements to ensure they are enforceable and comply with relevant laws and regulations.

 

·         Transparent Communication

 

Maintain open communication with clients regarding the implications of personal guarantees. Ensure that guarantors fully understand their obligations and the potential consequences of default or fraud.

 

Take Away Points

 

·         Personal guarantees play a crucial role in mitigating the risks associated with invoice finance fraud.

 

·         By providing an additional layer of security, they help finance providers manage their exposure to fraudulent activities and default.

 

·         The effective use of personal guarantees requires thorough vetting, clear contractual terms, and ongoing monitoring. Both finance providers and businesses must adopt best practices to ensure the integrity of the invoice finance process, thereby protecting all stakeholders involved.

 

·         Through diligence and transparency, the risks of invoice finance fraud can be significantly reduced.

 

If you require any assistance with the enforcement of a personal guarantee, contact our team of experts by emailing

joanna.bucklety@greenhalghkerr.com or telephoning 0333 200 5220.

 

Greenhalgh Kerr
Olympic House, Beecham Court,
Smithy Brook Rd,
Wigan WN3 6PR

View on google maps

+44 (0)333 200 5200

We are confident in our work and we know that recoveries is a key part of a lender or creditor’s business

We are confident in our work and we know that recoveries is a key part of a lender or creditor’s business. We have designed our pilot projects to give lenders and creditors the comfort and confidence in our service before formally and fully switching recoveries providers. This time also allows new clients to benchmark our service levers and results against existing providers and others.

How it works

01

You choose 10 recoveries cases

You choose 10 recoveries cases to get us started. We’ll deliver our usual onboarding protocol where we’ll get to know you and your systems, culture, methods, preferences, and requirements.

02

We get started

We assess each case by setting a strategy then grading and reporting on the case in terms of prospects and timescales and cost. We make immediate contact with debtors, and pursue a recovery in our tried and tested ways.

03

We review

We deliver ongoing, structured, tailored reports as per your needs and carry out a full 3-month review on these 20 cases. There we’ll discuss how we have worked together, patterns we have seen in your borrowers, your systems, your documents, your pre-legal conduct, outcomes, highs and lows, legal costs (and costs borne by debtors), and possible improvements in all of these.

04

No strings

We carry on working in this way until all cases have been concluded. You are then free to carry on your discussions with us or to use the experience and market intelligence gained by working with us in the future.

Lenders and creditors have nothing to lose, and everything to gain, by engaging with us on a pilot project.