“Freeman” director fails in bid to avoid NNDR liability

Image: Ricardo Gomez Angel/ripato/Unsplash
Image: Ricardo Gomez Angel/ripato/Unsplash

Background

Greenhalgh Kerr was instructed by a Welsh local authority to recover unpaid National Non-Domestic Rates (“NNDR”) owed by a limited company. The Council had already obtained liability orders in the Magistrates’ Court, with the outstanding debt totalling approximately £8,000.

The Company’s director was a known “freeman of the land” and had a history of advancing spurious arguments to avoid payment. Despite prior engagement with the Council, no meaningful progress had been made.

Early Assessment and Enforcement Strategy

Upon instruction, Greenhalgh Kerr promptly reviewed the Company’s financial position, including its trading status and asset base. Our assessment confirmed that the Company appeared profitable and asset-rich, with good prospects of recovery. We advised the Council accordingly and recommended insolvency-based enforcement if payment was not forthcoming.

A formal letter before action was immediately issued, allowing 14 days for payment and clearly warning that winding up proceedings would follow in default, with further costs being sought.

Dealing with Vexatious Arguments

Shortly thereafter, the director contacted our office asserting that the hereditament was “uninhabitable” and therefore not rateable. He was advised that the property remained listed by the Valuation Office Agency and that, while it remained on the rating list, the Council was under a statutory duty to bill and collect NNDR.

The director then escalated matters by asserting that liability orders were not “real” court orders and threatening legal action. These arguments were firmly and succinctly rebutted, and the director was advised to seek independent legal advice before the deadline expired.

Winding Up Proceedings

No payment or further engagement was received. Following expiry of the deadline, a winding up petition was presented and served at the Company’s registered office.

The day after the petition’s service, the director instructed a legal consultancy service, which forwarded on extensive and repetitive correspondence from the Company raising alleged disputes, demanding disclosure of privileged communications, and seeking information to which the Company was not entitled. Greenhalgh Kerr responded robustly on the Council’s behalf, while ensuring the Council did not engage directly so as to protect its position.

The Company was warned that, absent payment in full within seven business days, the petition would be advertised in the London Gazette pursuant to the Insolvency Rules.

Urgent Injunction Application and Resolution

Shortly thereafter, the director notified us of an urgent injunction application listed the following day in the Business and Property Court, seeking to restrain advertisement of the petition. Acting swiftly, we obtained a copy of the application, advised the Council, and instructed our in-house barrister, Alex Worthington to attend.

At the hearing, following submissions from Alex and subsequent negotiations between the parties, the matter was settled by consent on the day of the hearing. The Company paid the full NNDR debt together with all enforcement and legal costs incurred. The petition was withdrawn and the injunction application dismissed.

Conclusion

This case demonstrates Greenhalgh Kerr’s ability to act decisively and cost-effectively for local authority clients, particularly when faced with vexatious debtors advancing pseudo-legal arguments. Through early strategic advice and firm procedural control, full recovery was achieved with all costs paid by the debtor.

If you’re pursuing a difficult debtor for unpaid business rates and/or council tax debts and would like us to assist / offer guidance, please email info@greenhalghkerr.com. Our friendly and experienced team will be happy to assist you!

 

Danny Curtin

January 2026

Greenhalgh Kerr
Olympic House, Beecham Court,
Smithy Brook Rd,
Wigan WN3 6PR

View on google maps

+44 (0)333 200 5200

We are confident in our work and we know that recoveries is a key part of a lender or creditor’s business

We are confident in our work and we know that recoveries is a key part of a lender or creditor’s business. We have designed our pilot projects to give lenders and creditors the comfort and confidence in our service before formally and fully switching recoveries providers. This time also allows new clients to benchmark our service levers and results against existing providers and others.

How it works

01

You choose 10 recoveries cases

You choose 10 recoveries cases to get us started. We’ll deliver our usual onboarding protocol where we’ll get to know you and your systems, culture, methods, preferences, and requirements.

02

We get started

We assess each case by setting a strategy then grading and reporting on the case in terms of prospects and timescales and cost. We make immediate contact with debtors, and pursue a recovery in our tried and tested ways.

03

We review

We deliver ongoing, structured, tailored reports as per your needs and carry out a full 3-month review on these 20 cases. There we’ll discuss how we have worked together, patterns we have seen in your borrowers, your systems, your documents, your pre-legal conduct, outcomes, highs and lows, legal costs (and costs borne by debtors), and possible improvements in all of these.

04

No strings

We carry on working in this way until all cases have been concluded. You are then free to carry on your discussions with us or to use the experience and market intelligence gained by working with us in the future.

Lenders and creditors have nothing to lose, and everything to gain, by engaging with us on a pilot project.
Greenhalgh Kerr | Solicitors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.